Website Design

I was asked to do an evaluation of three different public school websites. I used the 113 Design Guidelines for Homepage Usability by the Nielson Norman Group.

The following are my general thoughts on these websites.

TRUSD

  • The site has a clean and modern design.

  • The site is easy to navigate.

  • Archived news and announcements are searchable.

  • Design elements are too large for a standard 1920 x 1080 screen.

  • Contact information is difficult to find and there is no vehicle for immediate feedback.

SPS

  • The homepage feels like an informational dashboard.

  • The main rotator and links are above the fold.

  • A detailed staff directory is publicly accessible which shows open positions and internal phone extensions.

  • The homepage is too visually busy making it difficult to use if you are unfamiliar with the site.

NPS

  • The accessibility and page translation widgets are top notch.

  • The site is clean and free of distracting graphics.

  • There are inconsistencies in font, text spacing, and layout.

  • The homepage is nothing more than a link page.

The tables below show my thoughts on the general design of 3 publicly viewable websites for educational institutions. The criteria are based on the Nielson Norman Group’s guidelines for homepage design.